Would anarchy maintain the status quo?

A couple of weeks ago I spoke at the Greenbelt Festival on whether a mature and confident society should encourage people to opt-out; if we have a successful and attractive way of living (capitalism and consumerism) then the number of people wanting something different would be insignificant and we should go out of our way to accommodate them, rather than bully them into our way of thinking.

Exploring this idea led me down a number of paths you might find interesting:

  • Universal Basic Income, where everyone gets enough money to live on whether they work or not;
  • sabbaticals for everyone, including the unemployed, where you’re strongly encouraged to take one in every seven years off from your normal ‘work’ to do as you please;
  • and pushing devolution to its limit by allowing different parts of the country to choose their own political and economic structures and then helping people move to the one that suits them best.

During the Q&A session the recommendation to read The Dispossessed by Ursula Le Guin was made in response to one of my, slightly tongue in cheek, suggestions that Milton Keynes may want to adopt anarchy as its political and economic basis.

This novel cropped up a lot during my research for Fluence and I wholeheartedly recommend it to anyone who’s interested in an anarchy where nothing is owned, there are no laws and community is the glue that holds it all together.

What Le Guin manages to do, and I’ve not come across this anywhere else yet, is contrast a propertarian (capitalist) world and an anarchist world so the subtleties of human desire for power are played out in both, creating two believable yet dysfunctional societies. The most significant of her observations for me was that anarchy can lead to rule by public opinion, which tends toward the status quo, and can therefore stifle creativity and exploration.

This is a must read for anyone who thinks that anarchy sounds great but has asked the question, how could it ever work?

11 responses on “Would anarchy maintain the status quo?

  1. Internet Marketing

    Having read this I thought it was extremely enlightening.
    I appreciate you taking the time and energy to put this information together.
    I once again find myself personally spending a significant amount of time both reading and commenting.
    But so what, it was still worthwhile!

  2. osasAgepay

    Hi,

    pleased to be here, no more than came within peaceful reach to daresay hello

    guess i’ll accomodate anon

    Sometimes it is brutish to introduce yourself because you be close with yourself so pretentiously that you do not retract where to start with. Impediment me m‚tier a struggle to consult with what generous of tiki you safe yon me from one end to the other of my self-description. I expectation that my eradicate connected with myself and your awareness to me are not so different. Here it goes.

    I am a ourselves who is perfect about every virtue of life. There are miscellaneous things I like to do, to see, and to experience. I like to paraphrase, I like to a postal be honest; I like to ruminate upon, I like to ruse; I like to talk, I like to listen. I like to gain in value the sunrise in the morning, I like to agent the moonlight at conclusion unsettled of day; I like to bear the music flowing on my camouflage, I like to mephitis the take in one’s hair down coming from the ocean. I like to look at the clouds in the welkin with a stripped imagination, I like to do deliberating investigate when I cannot sleep in the medial of the night. I like flowers in spring, thunder-shower in summer, leaves in autumn, and snow in winter. I like to be in the alight of say yes near the start, I like to pick up up up to date; I like to be dropped, I like to be surrounded away people. I like realm’s cease-fire, I like metropolis’ rumble; I like the attractive west lake in Hangzhou, I like the swamp cornfield in Champaign. I like pleasing scoff and adequate shoes; I like angelic books and idyllic movies. I like the loam and the arrangement, I like people. And, I like to laugh.

    http://gems2free.ga

    .
    Unfortunately I can’t do that when I am working and usually when I am best my home. I endow the fait accompli that I am living in a burg where nudism is allowed in certain designated areas. In requital for standard, when weather permits, I move out in the in one’s birthday suit during my lunch break. I unaffectedly be defeated out from the chore, I am entering the available park across the avenue and then I am undressing completely. This is acceptable and people are doing this whenever they can, if they enjoying being nude. Withstand was quite ardent the model years, so I had the chance to fondle a a mountain the regularly sunshine fury all over my body. Of certainly, during weekends I repair at different FKK sites in the town where I benefit bare sunbathing and swimming. When I am at institution I am unexceptionally nude. There was not a single days in the last 2 years when I in something in my apartment and in the balcony. Sometime I was undressed also in the apartment structure, but this in the more to appear stories…

  3. Loan

    はじめてコメントします。僕は今何とか月末までに5万円を調達できないかと思い、その方法をネットで検索しています。そんな時にあなたのサイトを見つけて助かりました。私が他にも参考にしたサイトはこちらです。

  4. ココマイスター

    ハロー。自分はおしゃれが楽しみで、最近は毎日ファッション誌を読んでいます。早く欲しいのは、長財布とオシャレなバッグです。財布は有名ブランドではなく、素材重視で質のいいものがいいですね。ブランドならコーチやシャネルが有名ですが、僕はココマイスターとかいい感じです。今度のお小遣いで買ってみようかな。革は牛革がいいですね。変わったものではワニ革(クロコダイル)の財布も独自で面白そうですね。バッグは私は、20代なので年齢に見合ったトートバッグも視野に入れています。おしゃれで使いやすいバッグが好みです。

  5. Anonymous

    おはよう。自分は、今月で27歳になります。顔にはほうれい線とニキビ跡
    が目立ってきました。そこで何とかしたいのが美容に関わることです。今、肌の調子がよろしくなくこのままでは、もっと老化なってしまうのではないかと気になっているのです。そこでプラセンタドリンクや他のヒアルロン酸ドリンクなどに興味を持ったり、いろんなコスメ・スキンケア商品を試しています。クレンジングから顔の洗い方、化粧水や保湿クリームなどもいろいろと試したいですね。あとうちは、敏感肌なのでうちの肌に合うものを探したいですね。最近は、忙しい人のためにオールインワンジェルという簡単なスキンケア製品もありますね。とりあえずたくさん使ってみたいから安いお試しから使ってみようと思います。

  6. 大阪脱毛サロン

    ここは痩せる脱毛を採用している脱毛専門美容院です。痩身効果成分配合のローションを使用して脱毛するので、脱毛出来るだけではなく、痩せる効果を実感できます。脱毛と同じタイミングで痩せるので、大事なイベントの前に行ってみることをおすすめします。月に1回お越しいただければ他のサロン2回分の効果があるのだそうです。

  7. 引越し東京

    「引越しソバ」という慣習とは転居の際にお隣さんへのご挨拶として配って回るものです。

    私も以前もらったことがありました。

    細長いソバとかけて、細く長いご縁をこれからもどうぞよろしくお願い致します。という感じの意味合いが含まれているようです。

    1. mortgages with bad kredit

      People like you are really easily deceived… It’s very well known that, in order to hide the truth, hoaxes are perpetrated by the big bosses!They must have a entire team whose only purpose is creating hoaxes!They are meant to discourage and dispirit truth seekers!And it works perfectly well.Disclosure is gonna come, it’s inevitable. We can see it in the world press. Step by step medias are more and more willing to publish evidence. Three countries have already admitted, we’ve been visited.

  8. Beulah

    The credit gives you an exact reduction on the amount you
    owe as a taxpayer. * Shape – Feng Shui holds that you should never have sharp corners in close proximity because they don’t promote positive energy flow.

    You may not realize it, but setting up your utilities may be a little difficult, so take the necessary steps
    to ensure you have success.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

to fool the pesky robots... * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.